Is Sarah Jane Nader Single or Dating? All About the 'Love Thy Nader' Star's Relationship History | Just Jared

Sarah Jane Nader is making her Dancing with the Stars debut tonight (September 16)!

The 24-year-old model and Love Thy Nader reality star is the second female celebrity to have a female pro partner on the show. She is competing alongside Hailey Bills, who was promoted to pro from the troupe.

3

Why Sarah Jane Nader is paired with a female pro on DWTS

Sarah Jane came out as bisexual on season one of Love Thy Nader, and she wanted a female dance partner, according to DWTS executive producer Conrad Green.

“Sarah Jane is bi[sexual], and she just wanted to have a female partner. It was just something about the dynamic of those two together,” he told The Wrap. “We kept coming back to [them] and going, those two, they look good.”

“And Hailey’s totally up for it,” he added.

Sarah Jane previously opened up about the significance of bringing home a woman to meet her family on Love Thy Nader.

“It was a huge moment for me because we’ve never talked about my sexuality. I’m very close to my extended family, and I love them, but it has always been sort of something that I felt like was just ignored and even danced around,” she told Variety. “No one would want to know about my dating life because they would be scared that it would come up. When I had a girlfriend that I loved very much before [her], I was too scared to bring her home. I didn’t want to put her under the pressure of experiencing homophobia.”

So, about her dating life… At the time of this post, it appears that Sarah Jane Nader is single, but we have details on her past relationships and recent rumors.

Keep reading below to find out more…

3

Pete Davidson

In early August, it was reported that Sarah Jane and Pete Davidson were spotted going out on a date.

Deux Moi posted a video that was shared with them, where Pete lead the way and opened the passenger car door for Sarah Jane. He also held something for her as she got into the car, acting like a total gentleman on the date.

Sarah Jane‘s sister, Brooks Nader, reacted to Pete and Sarah Jane‘s supposed date, saying she was confused. Find out why!

@sarahjanenader From our trip home??? #LoveThyNader @Love Thy Nader @eliana #crawfishboil ? original sound – ADPI TENNESSEE

Eliana Orly

Sarah Jane previously dated photographer and creative director Eliana Orly, who was the woman she brought home on Love Thy Nader.

“Bringing Eliana was like dipping a toe in the water of, ‘I can do this. Maybe nobody will ask what the nature of our relationship is. Maybe they’ll say things behind my back.’ I didn’t know,” Nader told Variety. “But I didn’t care, because she’s experiencing Louisiana, and that was fun for me. It lifted this idea that it was going to be such a big deal. Then I brought her home, and nobody talked about it. It wasn’t a big deal.”

3

Alexis Williams

Sarah Jane also reportedly dated Alexis Williams, who became New York City’s Deputy Press Secretary for Culture Partnerships and Black Media after working on Mayor Zohran Mamdani‘s campaign.

While their relationship was not confirmed, they reportedly went on several dates and were “vibing.”

Camille Opp

Sarah Jane previously dated model Camille Opp for over a year.

In May 2024, she shared the above post, writing, “Happiest year yet,” with a red heart emoji.

While unconfirmed if Camille was the girlfriend she talked about, Sarah Jane said she had a girlfriend before introducing Eliana Orly to her family.

“When I had a girlfriend that I loved very much before Eliana, I was too scared to bring her home. I didn’t want to put her under the pressure of experiencing homophobia,” she told Variety.

Posted To:Dating History Sarah Jane Nader